?

Log in

No account? Create an account

Older Entry | Newer Entry

memories in book and movie

Saw Memoirs of a Geisha yesterday. Seeing it wth a freind who hadnt read the book made me aware of the gaps in the movie. The book takes you into the life of Sayuri. Of Japan, its pride, and its poverty. Of life before World War. Of an unexplored life, of the mysteries known as Geisha.
The movie somehow does not manage to highlight all that. It comes down to the love story of Sayuri and the Chairman. It is undeniably correct wrt the book, but misses out the essence of it. The author had introduced the Chairman for the sake of a string on which to tie the beads of the story, but the movie makes the thread too important and fat for the beads to stay on. The subtle politics, the importance of the bid, the arts of Geishas and enmity between Mameha and Hatsumomo are belittled as compared to their rivals from the book. The basic character of Sayuri remains skeletal, not the woman we learn to hope for in the book.

After having read the book ages ago, I still remember the nuances. After having waited for the movie for so long, I will remember the photography and the good cast. But not a movie Ill recommend. Go read the book, I say.

Alas, not for the first time, the book outdoes the movie...not that I mind ;)

Tags:


Digg!
 |  submit to reddit  |   |  Del.icio.us
___________________________________________________________

Comments

( 1 comment — Leave a comment )
sashdude
27th Nov, 2006 13:43 (UTC)
books will
always be better than movies, simply because you use your imagination when you read a book, as compared to what is presented from another viewpoint on screen.. there are a few exceptions to the rule though..
( 1 comment — Leave a comment )

About Me


Regurgitations of my mind. Specific, Vague, Memorable, Forgettable, Thoughtless, In-depth.

More variegated than your dreams or colours off a crystal. More than I can pen down. What I can, you can read.


Subscribe
Search within this site below:







myspace profile visitor

Page Summary

Latest Month

August 2016
S M T W T F S
 123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
28293031   
Powered by LiveJournal.com
Designed by Lizzy Enger