Forget about his pitch. His program. It is not for everyone. Plus he is a marketing guru, so the program makes sense for those who intend to be marketing people managing marketing companies...and live close to NY.
But I would appreciate if you read the post.
The post talks about changing your life. The point of the post is what he says about jumping the track, about the Stanford MBA giving him a chance to do something different.
I know Rex who took the chance and did an MBA. He still preferred what he had initially and returned to it - he is happy that he jumped and took the chance. Now he really knows what he likes. I know many others who loved the life post the jump. It did change life for them.
Overall, its reassuring and it reconfirms what I say about an MBA - an MBA essentially is something that gives you the fillip to move to something you otherwise could'nt have. An MBA may not be everyone's answer to a transition, or a change - or what my father called 'entering with an advantage'.
I did not want to be an Engineer or a Doctor. My parents wanted me to be both. I did the next best thing - gave an entrance exam and got myself into the best Science college of its time (and second best now) in India - Presidency College, Calcutta. Sure, I did Botany. But I enjoyed every bit of it - OK not every bit. I loathed Taxonomy. I just cant memorise names of plants given by fancy by an old now-dead scientists. I envied organic chemistry but then Zoology gave me hope. They simply dont have a nomenclature system. But I veer off-track.
At that time, in my house there were only select few career options open to me. On my fathers side, every single person is an Engineer - it was unimaginable to my grandfather that I was not going to do engineering. My other grandfather is a doctor. Everyone wants a doc at hand - so I was the choice.
But I did Botany.
There were a couple of choices open to me after that as far as my family saw it. The most obvious, and the one followed by my classmates was masters followed by a PhD. Most of the people who did graduation with me are submitting theses now. I could also get into IAS, but I dint want to.
The only thing that could change my life at that point was an MBA. An MBA was something general enough to give me a spring board to get into any industry I wanted, into a job. I never wanted to do commerce. I did science in school and I loved it. I did Botany in my graduation and it was amazing fun. So I changed my life after that to get a good job. I changed myself from becoming a scholar - though many of my professors lamented (and still do) at that. But then I did an MBA. And enjoyed it. Actually, I enjoyed it more than anything else I had done till then.
But the MBA prepared me. It changed me from what I was. Nothing intrinsic, but it gave a perspective. It channelised what I had. Like Seth mentions, an MBA is a finishing school, really. It teaches you how to work in groups, clearly, and be good at dealing with people. It enhances your skill at doing work fast. I met 160 people whom I would meet for the rest of my life - while I was not being judged. I learned how to understand people and figure out how to make them work. I saw some stalwarts manage people naturally and envied them bitterly.
Sure, when I went to work I was still a novice. Sure, I learned commerce and economics and finance and marketing and strategy and human relations management during my MBA. But what I really learnt was not there on the textbooks. It was an experience. It was a chance - it changed my life. It gave me a platform for easy entry into almost any industry, into almost any profile. From a Botany graduate struggling in work life with limited options and low pay, two years made me eligible for any industry I pleased.
Some of my college classmates are working now, after their MSc. However, their work is related to what masters they did, and they never really had an option when they started working. They dint change their life by one fell swoop, they changed it day after day working away at it. Nothing wrong with that, but its the hard way - or the easy way whichever your point of view is. Hard because it takes long to reach a level which can be reached in two years. Easy because then you dont really have to take a call as to what you want to do. Doing an MBA is taking a conscious decision that you want to change your life and that you want to do "x" thing, and that you need a platform for it. Its a smart choice.
There are some lucky people who know what they want. They don't need platforms and change their lives. But an MBA is a spring board for those who want to, smartly.
Of course, a lot depends on the institute and also depends on the country. In India now, its almost necessary to get and MBA - ts like an engineering degree - everyone has one. But when I did my MBA it was rare. How things change in 6 odd years!
It is also enlightening to see how perspectives change. How little I knew when I did my graduation - how few avenues were open. Computer Science was cutting edge and I almost joined it. There was a college offering a diploma in Advertising and it was a thing of awe.